{"count":100,"experiments":[{"created_at":1788074559.167969,"run_id":"discovery-1788074559167-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"cd0826048583-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788074559.207362,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","digest":"fbd088035a5c47c7"},{"created_at":1788074579.7966342,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"cd0826048583-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788074579.8396,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788074579796-390c1e","digest":"fbd088035a5c47c7"},{"created_at":1788074931.230069,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"b39bcbdf53fc-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788074931.2766788,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788074931230-390c1e","digest":"c1d14b5b71d33ed7"},{"created_at":1788075590.082381,"kind":"discovery","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"0cf09c9c108a-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788075590.125164,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"digest":"fffc2cf100f2f3cc","run_id":"discovery-1788075590082-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788075610.070899,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"0cf09c9c108a-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788075610.110452,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"fffc2cf100f2f3cc","run_id":"discovery-1788075610070-390c1e","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788075845.963905,"kind":"discovery","notes":"","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"0596f9d551f0-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788075846.012108,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"ee9ba89f83eee6b3","run_id":"discovery-1788075845963-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788075867.192138,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"0596f9d551f0-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"recorded_at":1788075867.232695},"digest":"ee9ba89f83eee6b3","run_id":"discovery-1788075867192-390c1e","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788077115.9585888,"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788077115958-390c1e","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"aa6457a94bfe1bcc","notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"e6255c5e6e65-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788077116.001579,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}}},{"created_at":1788077192.7390962,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"d68c52150a06","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788077192.7785752,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"34e8782692fce9e1","run_id":"discovery-1788077192739-390c1e","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788077776.639536,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00004-5xk","recorded_at":1788077776.6413553,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.15"},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788077776639-390c1e","digest":"87c767e6d74dd832"},{"created_at":1788077786.133722,"digest":"8ae13a35c0c1b48a","notes":"","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788077786133-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"2e9e7fe19a56-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788077786.173565,"schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788077819.9225504,"config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":200,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"gemini-1260","paired_arms":false},"margin":0.02,"n_worlds":24,"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"notes":"","seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"parent":"champion-v1","audit":{"confidence":0.85,"concern":"Accuracy fell by 0.0278, which exceeds the noise threshold of 0.02 and indicates a trade-off where sample size was reduced at the expense of correct causal identifications.","legitimate":false,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin","challenger_parts":{"score":0.8981486111111111,"worlds":24,"cost":0.05555555555555556,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"challenger_score":0.8981,"verdict":"PROMOTED","candidate":"gemini-1260","champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"receipt_digest":"0f1e4dcae5906dc3","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[200,400]},"champion_score":0.8704},"trials":[],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00004-5xk","recorded_at":1788077819.9235296,"models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"python":"3.13.15"},"kind":"evolution","run_id":"evolution-1788077819922-c30b01","digest":"a9fa5f0181573493"},{"created_at":1788078102.0041301,"kind":"discovery","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"2e9e7fe19a56-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788078102.046304,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"8ae13a35c0c1b48a","run_id":"discovery-1788078102004-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788078250.2316391,"notes":"","kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"f16d1ed831ba4710","run_id":"discovery-1788078250231-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"e3d6125973dc","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788078250.268078,"schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788078334.3059468,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"e3d6125973dc-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788078334.377336,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"1ce40fdfcfbfa6f1","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788078334305-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788078418.237217,"provenance":{"git_commit":"96da5b7f4ee9-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788078418.279131,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"1f3691f40f9feb60","run_id":"discovery-1788078418237-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788078727.302326,"run_id":"discovery-1788078727302-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"aa8b4939f6ac-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788078727.352662,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"digest":"4e8a815f88f3e810","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788078793.007133,"provenance":{"git_commit":"aa8b4939f6ac-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788078793.053056,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"4e8a815f88f3e810","run_id":"discovery-1788078793007-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788078825.0368068,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"4e8a815f88f3e810","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"aa8b4939f6ac-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788078825.081101,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788078825036-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788078992.902624,"digest":"57ce4ed8afefceca","notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"cb67d9e08c5b-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788078992.9426749,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788078992902-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788079033.234782,"kind":"discovery","provenance":{"git_commit":"cb67d9e08c5b-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"recorded_at":1788079033.284396},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"57ce4ed8afefceca","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788079033234-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788079517.155261,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"019e6b4248bc-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788079517.2101812,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"3883a595fd662e28","run_id":"discovery-1788079517155-390c1e","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788079643.066967,"notes":"","kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"019e6b4248bc-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788079643.112318,"schema_version":1},"digest":"3883a595fd662e28","run_id":"discovery-1788079643066-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788079782.572256,"notes":"","kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"9833088c4bda-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788079782.629581,"schema_version":1},"digest":"e2147124ea554079","run_id":"discovery-1788079782572-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788079838.026876,"provenance":{"git_commit":"9833088c4bda-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788079838.074123,"schema_version":1,"python":"3.13.7"},"run_id":"discovery-1788079838026-390c1e","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"e2147124ea554079","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788080321.545495,"notes":"","digest":"9f591549fbfabedb","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"3abe0d820d77-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788080321.6016152,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788080321545-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788080473.435018,"notes":"","kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"9f591549fbfabedb","run_id":"discovery-1788080473435-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"3abe0d820d77-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788080473.483689,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}}},{"created_at":1788080512.7985191,"digest":"9f591549fbfabedb","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"3abe0d820d77-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788080512.8569689,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788080512798-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788081000.181174,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"4da2af8b13c6-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788081000.246999,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"digest":"d28878e77800336d","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788081000181-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788081025.818846,"provenance":{"git_commit":"4da2af8b13c6-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788081025.869527,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788081025818-390c1e","digest":"d28878e77800336d"},{"created_at":1788081998.552651,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"47b0946181265e38","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"66e87086d02a-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788081998.616139,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788081998552-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788082056.3541918,"digest":"47b0946181265e38","provenance":{"git_commit":"66e87086d02a-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788082056.403496},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788082056354-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788082084.059212,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"47b0946181265e38","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"66e87086d02a-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788082084.120568,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788082084059-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788083109.5838091,"provenance":{"git_commit":"085ce0d3c213-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788083109.626101,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"run_id":"discovery-1788083109583-390c1e","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","digest":"7aaf64a18b75b56b"},{"created_at":1788083132.284628,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"085ce0d3c213-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788083132.336637},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788083132284-390c1e","digest":"7aaf64a18b75b56b"},{"created_at":1788083157.274761,"provenance":{"git_commit":"085ce0d3c213-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083157.3267782,"schema_version":1,"python":"3.13.7"},"kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"7aaf64a18b75b56b","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788083157274-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788083233.73722,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"085ce0d3c213-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788083233.785239,"schema_version":1},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788083233737-390c1e","digest":"7aaf64a18b75b56b"},{"created_at":1788083259.308018,"run_id":"discovery-1788083259308-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"085ce0d3c213-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083259.360094,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"7aaf64a18b75b56b","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788083366.174604,"provenance":{"git_commit":"a3e710cba311","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788083366.2229161},"kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"3128b44c3568ad40","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788083366174-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788083410.9094248,"run_id":"discovery-1788083410909-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"a3e710cba311-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083410.9609568,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"digest":"52647212ad35de4f","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788083436.976656,"kind":"discovery","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"a3e710cba311-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788083437.027444,"schema_version":1},"digest":"52647212ad35de4f","run_id":"discovery-1788083436976-390c1e","notes":""},{"created_at":1788083532.7801018,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"a3e710cba311-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083532.833659,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"digest":"52647212ad35de4f","run_id":"discovery-1788083532780-390c1e","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788083573.389628,"provenance":{"git_commit":"a3e710cba311-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083573.441101,"schema_version":1,"python":"3.13.7"},"run_id":"discovery-1788083573389-390c1e","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"52647212ad35de4f","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788083727.384235,"provenance":{"git_commit":"f6fa4b196681-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083727.4389608,"schema_version":1,"python":"3.13.7"},"run_id":"discovery-1788083727384-390c1e","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"106004908f46d2de","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788083770.240715,"kind":"discovery","provenance":{"git_commit":"f6fa4b196681-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788083770.289654,"schema_version":1,"python":"3.13.7"},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"106004908f46d2de","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788083770240-390c1e"},{"created_at":1788083835.929975,"notes":"","digest":"106004908f46d2de","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"f6fa4b196681-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788083835.983286,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788083835929-390c1e","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788084135.301705,"notes":"depth=0 complex=True","digest":"87c767e6d74dd832","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T7","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T7","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.2568,"form":"modulus","coeffs":{"X5":1.1976,"X1":1.0112}},"X2":{"const":0.3691,"form":"imag","coeffs":{"X1":0.6839}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X5":[],"X1":[],"X3":["X5","X1"],"X2":["X1"]},"complex_vars":{"X4":["X5","X1"]}},"variables":["X5","X1","X3","X2"],"model":{"X1->X2":0.6823},"world_seed":7,"refutations":11,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":0.6667,"mae":0.098,"probes":6},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":0.6823,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0118,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":0.0099,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0118,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.0224,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0097,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0144,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.0093,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X5"},{"measured_effect":-0.0144,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0118,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X5"},{"measured_effect":-0.0144,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.015,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X5"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788084135301-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00010-mvd","python":"3.13.15","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"recorded_at":1788084135.3043592}},{"created_at":1788084294.8709555,"notes":"","digest":"a9fa5f0181573493","seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"trials":[],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"audit":{"legitimate":false,"concern":"Accuracy fell by 0.0278, which exceeds the noise threshold of 0.02 and represents a real drop in scientific discovery quality traded away for cheaper measurements.","confidence":0.85,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"parent":"champion-v1","reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin","challenger_parts":{"score":0.8981486111111111,"worlds":24,"cost":0.05555555555555556,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"challenger_score":0.8981,"verdict":"PROMOTED","candidate":"gemini-1260","champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"receipt_digest":"0dc61918935ce218","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[200,400]},"champion_score":0.8704},"config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":200,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"gemini-1260","paired_arms":false},"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false},"n_worlds":24,"margin":0.02},"kind":"evolution","run_id":"evolution-1788084294870-c30b01","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00010-mvd","python":"3.13.15","models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"recorded_at":1788084294.8721206}},{"created_at":1788084523.746615,"digest":"4b086c650ccc8cd3","notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"trust_observation":false,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788084523746-390c1e","provenance":{"git_commit":"a3afba3cdd7a-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788084523.799007,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}}},{"created_at":1788085630.695907,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"cd72a0658064-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788085630.772543,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788085630695-871cf2","digest":"9a4b052938b6881f"},{"created_at":1788085713.799434,"digest":"9a4b052938b6881f","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"cd72a0658064-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788085713.8958879,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788085713799-871cf2"},{"created_at":1788085755.541406,"digest":"9a4b052938b6881f","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"cd72a0658064-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788085755.5947242,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788085755541-871cf2","notes":""},{"created_at":1788085823.209836,"provenance":{"git_commit":"cd72a0658064-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788085823.267112,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"9a4b052938b6881f","run_id":"discovery-1788085823209-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788085851.839991,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"cd72a0658064-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788085851.88852,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"digest":"9a4b052938b6881f","run_id":"discovery-1788085851839-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788085966.618624,"run_id":"discovery-1788085966618-871cf2","digest":"9a4b052938b6881f","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"cd72a0658064-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788085966.667539,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}}},{"created_at":1788089584.061604,"run_id":"discovery-1788089584061-871cf2","provenance":{"git_commit":"7fb118459fc5-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788089584.252625,"schema_version":1},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"8e2e75546183380a","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788089690.206741,"provenance":{"git_commit":"784b11edbe63","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788089690.285506,"schema_version":1},"run_id":"discovery-1788089690206-871cf2","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","digest":"aeae2aa8784d9bc7"},{"created_at":1788090624.277929,"provenance":{"git_commit":"a6231a11fd64-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788090624.325464,"schema_version":1},"digest":"7b04cd955a2c726a","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788090624277-871cf2","notes":""},{"created_at":1788103210.804586,"run_id":"discovery-1788103210804-871cf2","kind":"discovery","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"d6da7849ba6e768f","notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"4b0d229b3205-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788103210.851754}},{"created_at":1788103215.512867,"provenance":{"git_commit":"4b0d229b3205-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788103215.551063,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788103215512-871cf2","digest":"d6da7849ba6e768f"},{"created_at":1788109097.0414531,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"972d224a7b31-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788109097.091894,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"d27c2a8390b83ee1","run_id":"discovery-1788109097041-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788111345.837248,"kind":"discovery","notes":"","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"ce154f139043-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788111345.8809202,"schema_version":1},"digest":"831641b10603bd88","run_id":"discovery-1788111345837-871cf2","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788114777.665328,"provenance":{"git_commit":"0a2fa5e2aab8-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788114777.710212,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"python":"3.13.7"},"digest":"56a56e0d65071139","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788114777665-871cf2","notes":""},{"created_at":1788114809.571744,"notes":"","digest":"56a56e0d65071139","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788114809571-871cf2","provenance":{"git_commit":"0a2fa5e2aab8-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788114809.61883,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}}},{"created_at":1788115916.1467662,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"f9809da4c98b-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788115916.187712,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788115916146-871cf2","digest":"97c4f5f9520cf880"},{"created_at":1788122320.915993,"run_id":"discovery-1788122320915-871cf2","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"b5af11d77bee","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788122320.957963,"schema_version":1},"digest":"5aaa534e29b61481","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788123130.755071,"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788123130755-871cf2","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"4c86b237c360a3fe","notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"404f48064746-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788123130.798911,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}}},{"created_at":1788125536.699028,"digest":"31846a0675672b70","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"8ef93fe22523-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788125536.7469199},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788125536699-871cf2","notes":""},{"created_at":1788126165.953965,"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788126165953-871cf2","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"eb0bd4fc3e49-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788126166.0019882,"schema_version":1},"digest":"5aee4d765e7cd580","notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788127474.037005,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"7677ae835e35","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788127474.079424,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1},"digest":"d82d780d20d6a36b","run_id":"discovery-1788127474037-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788128494.067786,"digest":"42e8b8a26ce9ef60","provenance":{"git_commit":"4455ece10ffd-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788128494.113989,"schema_version":1},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788128494067-871cf2","notes":""},{"created_at":1788129249.77072,"kind":"discovery","provenance":{"git_commit":"1adfc1f816f9-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788129249.8128371,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"b24b08cd35fcb2e9","run_id":"discovery-1788129249770-871cf2","notes":""},{"created_at":1788158288.179084,"run_id":"discovery-1788158288179-871cf2","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"provenance":{"git_commit":"240c8d64ae05-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788158288.218007,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","digest":"00069068801559ef"},{"created_at":1788158320.7130291,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"00069068801559ef","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"240c8d64ae05-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788158320.757864,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788158320713-871cf2"},{"created_at":1788159429.630054,"notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"efb12ecc7846-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788159429.6760619,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"ac3cb25658313ebf","run_id":"discovery-1788159429630-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788164654.21197,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"41aabb0d0b7e-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788164654.252339},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"3c0e46314406b530","run_id":"discovery-1788164654211-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788165090.099146,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"6c3e49c12bcb1ed5","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"c947f74f007d-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788165090.175961},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788165090099-871cf2"},{"created_at":1788172680.7915807,"run_id":"discovery-1788172680791-871cf2","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00011-rhk","python":"3.13.15","recorded_at":1788172680.7944636,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"454d9f68369a420f","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788172689.712885,"run_id":"discovery-1788172689712-871cf2","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00011-rhk","python":"3.13.15","recorded_at":1788172689.71399,"models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"454d9f68369a420f","notes":"","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788172797.8018253,"run_id":"evolution-1788172797801-6a4ee2","config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":200,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"gemini-1260","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false},"margin":0.02,"n_worlds":24,"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"audit":{"confidence":0.85,"concern":"The system improved its composite score by sacrificing accuracy to achieve a larger reduction in measurement cost, trading off scientific correctness for a cheaper shortcut.","legitimate":false,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin","parent":"champion-v1","challenger_parts":{"score":0.8981486111111111,"worlds":24,"cost":0.05555555555555556,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"challenger_score":0.8981,"receipt_digest":"77270b936927dab1","candidate":"gemini-1260","champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"verdict":"PROMOTED","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[200,400]},"champion_score":0.8704},"trials":[],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00011-rhk","python":"3.13.15","recorded_at":1788172797.8031888,"models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"}},"digest":"fd52c9a392d2c9c3","notes":"","kind":"evolution"},{"created_at":1788172938.2882729,"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"image":"metascience-00011-rhk","python":"3.13.15","recorded_at":1788172938.2904124,"schema_version":1},"notes":"","seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"parent":"champion-v1","audit":{"legitimate":false,"concern":"The score increase was driven by a significant drop in measurement cost that outweighed a real decrease in accuracy from 0.9815 to 0.9537.","confidence":0.85,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin","challenger_parts":{"score":0.8981486111111111,"worlds":24,"cost":0.05555555555555556,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"candidate":"gemini-1260","verdict":"PROMOTED","challenger_score":0.8981,"champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"receipt_digest":"84cb24237ac5d6dc","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[200,400]},"champion_score":0.8704},"trials":[],"config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":200,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"gemini-1260","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false},"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false},"n_worlds":24,"margin":0.02},"digest":"fd52c9a392d2c9c3","run_id":"evolution-1788172938288-6a4ee2","kind":"evolution"},{"created_at":1788173455.828524,"digest":"edae78bbf8ea89ba","provenance":{"git_commit":"b41b20649dd6-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"recorded_at":1788173455.881589},"seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","run_id":"discovery-1788173455828-871cf2"},{"created_at":1788173964.021155,"digest":"22b18d3954dcb785","run_id":"discovery-1788173964021-871cf2","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"7db324fcb54f","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","recorded_at":1788173964.085462,"schema_version":1},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788175544.41563,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"7db324fcb54f-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"recorded_at":1788175544.4833012},"digest":"180131fc77d36b2d","run_id":"discovery-1788175544415-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788176333.9882371,"notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"cf36c4f789d9-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","recorded_at":1788176334.051913,"python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"predicted_sign":1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"predicted_sign":-1,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"8008b597a3739e6e","run_id":"discovery-1788176333988-871cf2","kind":"discovery"},{"created_at":1788192456.402836,"run_id":"discovery-1788192456402-871cf2","digest":"2ec0d03f0c78fe58","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X3":["X2","X1"],"X2":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"62e0749a5d5c-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788192456.449443,"schema_version":1,"python":"3.13.7"},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}}},{"created_at":1788198024.823534,"provenance":{"git_commit":"bd3308ecbe33-dirty","schema_version":1,"image":"local","python":"3.13.7","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"recorded_at":1788198024.873937},"run_id":"discovery-1788198024823-871cf2","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"form":"exponential","const":0.757,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"effect_threshold":0.15,"parent":null,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","digest":"698ecccb8fe7b2e0"},{"created_at":1788198179.9724562,"kind":"discovery","notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"454d9f68369a420f","run_id":"discovery-1788198179972-871cf2","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","recorded_at":1788198179.9746153,"python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788198208.593932,"digest":"698ecccb8fe7b2e0","run_id":"discovery-1788198208593-871cf2","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4}}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"bd3308ecbe33-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788198208.646465,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788198236.5752,"kind":"discovery","notes":"","seeds":[7],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.5237,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0086,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.4025,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0109,"cause":"X2"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"454d9f68369a420f","run_id":"discovery-1788198236575-871cf2","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","recorded_at":1788198236.5760837,"python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788198241.800216,"notes":"","digest":"698ecccb8fe7b2e0","seeds":[7],"trials":[{"template_id":"T2","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T2","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X2","X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X3":{"const":0.757,"form":"exponential","coeffs":{"X1":-1.1229,"X2":0.9269}}}},"variables":["X2","X1","X3"],"model":{"X1->X3":-3.5237,"X2->X3":0.4025},"world_seed":7,"refutations":4,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0202,"probes":4},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-3.5237,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0086,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.4025,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":-0.0109,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"n":400,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"cause":"X2"}]}],"outcome":null,"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"kind":"discovery","run_id":"discovery-1788198241800-871cf2","provenance":{"git_commit":"bd3308ecbe33-dirty","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"local","recorded_at":1788198241.853321,"python":"3.13.7","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788198341.730781,"kind":"evolution","notes":"","seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"parent":"champion-v1","champion_score":0.8704,"audit":{"legitimate":false,"concern":"Accuracy fell by 0.0278, which exceeds the noise threshold of 0.02 and indicates that the score gain came from reducing measurement cost at the expense of causal discovery quality.","confidence":0.85,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"challenger_parts":{"score":0.9120375,"worlds":24,"cost":0.04166666666666668,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"candidate":"gemini-1740","receipt_digest":"71e229827ac6829c","challenger_score":0.912,"champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"verdict":"PROMOTED","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[150,400]},"reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin"},"trials":[],"config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":150,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"gemini-1740","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false},"margin":0.02,"n_worlds":24,"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"d68c0541e437e569","run_id":"evolution-1788198341730-1c2ca5","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","recorded_at":1788198341.7318861,"python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788198465.34469,"kind":"discovery","notes":"depth=1 complex=False","seeds":[310],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T3+T6","model":{"X6->X5":0.8596,"X1->X4":1.0198,"X3->X1":0.6463,"X2->X1":-0.801,"X2->X4":-0.8242,"X3->X4":0.6577},"variables":["X3","X2","X1","X4","X6","X5"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T3+T6","complex_vars":{},"hidden":["X7"],"edges":{"X6":["X2","X7"],"X5":["X7","X6"],"X4":["X1"],"X7":[],"X1":["X3","X2"],"X2":[],"X3":[]},"mechanisms":{"X6":{"const":0,"form":"linear","coeffs":{"X7":1.501,"X2":0.7442}},"X5":{"const":0,"form":"linear","coeffs":{"X6":0.9399,"X7":-3.9941}},"X4":{"const":0.469,"form":"linear","coeffs":{"X1":1.0239}},"X1":{"const":0.4362,"form":"linear","coeffs":{"X2":-0.8141,"X3":0.6631}}}},"world_seed":310,"refutations":7,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.0038,"probes":10},"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":1.0198,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0192,"cause":"X4"},{"n":400,"effect":"X6","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0225,"cause":"X5"},{"n":400,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.8596,"cause":"X6"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0091,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.801,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.8242,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0091,"cause":"X4"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0217,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.6463,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.6577,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0217,"cause":"X4"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"80476c69175e525a","run_id":"discovery-1788198465344-18ff5d","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","recorded_at":1788198465.3455412,"python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788198519.7830162,"kind":"evolution","notes":"","seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"parent":"champion-v1","champion_score":0.8704,"audit":{"legitimate":false,"concern":"The system lowered the sample size per arm, trading a noticeable drop in accuracy for a larger cost savings to artificially boost the composite score.","confidence":0.85,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"challenger_parts":{"score":0.9120375,"worlds":24,"cost":0.04166666666666668,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"candidate":"gemini-1740","receipt_digest":"fef9071ea1ca48fa","challenger_score":0.912,"champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"verdict":"PROMOTED","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[150,400]},"reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin"},"trials":[],"config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":150,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"gemini-1740","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false},"margin":0.02,"n_worlds":24,"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"name":"champion-v1","max_experiments":12,"paired_arms":false}},"digest":"d68c0541e437e569","run_id":"evolution-1788198519783-1c2ca5","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","recorded_at":1788198519.7839756,"python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1}},{"created_at":1788205476.3166401,"run_id":"discovery-1788205476316-523187","kind":"discovery","seeds":[64389],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T4+T4+T6+T6","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T4+T4+T6+T6","mechanisms":{"X10":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X3":1.2751,"X12":1.5536}},"X8":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X6":-0.5802,"X7":-4.1666,"X9":1.4111}},"X9":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X7":1.6635}},"X11":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X10":0.8138,"X8":1.1111,"X12":-4.273}},"X5":{"form":"linear","const":1.6395,"coeffs":{"X4":-1.9886,"X2":-0.8798}},"X4":{"form":"saturating","const":3.9769,"coeffs":{"X6":1.4023,"X3":-1.0784}},"X1":{"form":"saturating","const":2.9204,"coeffs":{"X3":2.2114}},"X2":{"form":"linear","const":0.5199,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.4685}}},"hidden":["X7","X12"],"edges":{"X6":[],"X7":[],"X3":[],"X10":["X12","X3"],"X8":["X6","X7","X9"],"X9":["X7"],"X11":["X10","X12","X8"],"X5":["X2","X4"],"X4":["X3","X6"],"X1":["X3"],"X2":["X1"],"X12":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X3","X1","X2","X6","X4","X5","X9","X8","X10","X11"],"model":{"X3->X1":2.0151,"X9->X8":1.1767,"X3->X2":-2.9679,"X1->X2":-1.4773,"X6->X4":1.8621,"X4->X5":-1.9361},"world_seed":64389,"refutations":7,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":0.5556,"mae":0.7281,"probes":18},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-1.4773,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":0.0346,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-1.9361,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X4"},{"measured_effect":0.0281,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X5"},{"measured_effect":0.0836,"effect":"X9","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X8"},{"measured_effect":1.1767,"effect":"X8","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X9"},{"measured_effect":0.0137,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":2.0151,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.0137,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-2.9679,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.0152,"effect":"X6","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X4"},{"measured_effect":1.8621,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X6"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"67b46276086f5aa7","notes":"depth=3 complex=False","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788205476.3186033}},{"created_at":1788205482.5882463,"run_id":"discovery-1788205482588-523187","kind":"discovery","seeds":[64389],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T4+T4+T6+T6","ground_truth":{"template_id":"T4+T4+T6+T6","mechanisms":{"X10":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X3":1.2751,"X12":1.5536}},"X8":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X6":-0.5802,"X7":-4.1666,"X9":1.4111}},"X9":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X7":1.6635}},"X11":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X10":0.8138,"X8":1.1111,"X12":-4.273}},"X5":{"form":"linear","const":1.6395,"coeffs":{"X4":-1.9886,"X2":-0.8798}},"X4":{"form":"saturating","const":3.9769,"coeffs":{"X6":1.4023,"X3":-1.0784}},"X1":{"form":"saturating","const":2.9204,"coeffs":{"X3":2.2114}},"X2":{"form":"linear","const":0.5199,"coeffs":{"X1":-1.4685}}},"hidden":["X7","X12"],"edges":{"X6":[],"X7":[],"X3":[],"X10":["X12","X3"],"X8":["X6","X7","X9"],"X9":["X7"],"X11":["X10","X12","X8"],"X5":["X2","X4"],"X4":["X3","X6"],"X1":["X3"],"X2":["X1"],"X12":[]},"complex_vars":{}},"variables":["X3","X1","X2","X6","X4","X5","X9","X8","X10","X11"],"model":{"X3->X1":2.0151,"X9->X8":1.1767,"X3->X2":-2.9679,"X1->X2":-1.4773,"X6->X4":1.8621,"X4->X5":-1.9361},"world_seed":64389,"refutations":7,"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":0.5556,"mae":0.7281,"probes":18},"experiments":[{"measured_effect":-1.4773,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":0.0346,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-1.9361,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X4"},{"measured_effect":0.0281,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X5"},{"measured_effect":0.0836,"effect":"X9","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X8"},{"measured_effect":1.1767,"effect":"X8","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X9"},{"measured_effect":0.0137,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X1"},{"measured_effect":2.0151,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.0137,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X2"},{"measured_effect":-2.9679,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X3"},{"measured_effect":0.0152,"effect":"X6","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X4"},{"measured_effect":1.8621,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"n":400,"cause":"X6"}]}],"config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"67b46276086f5aa7","notes":"depth=3 complex=False","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788205482.5893428}},{"created_at":1788206227.3499248,"run_id":"evolution-1788206227349-6a4ee2","kind":"evolution","seeds":[10000,10001,10002,10003,10004,10005,10006,10007,10008,10009,10010,10011,10012,10013,10014,10015,10016,10017,10018,10019,10020,10021,10022,10023],"outcome":{"margin_required":0.02,"audit":{"confidence":0.85,"concern":"The score improvement was driven by a significant reduction in measurement cost while accuracy dropped by 0.0278, which exceeds the noise threshold and indicates a genuine sacrifice in causal identification performance.","legitimate":false,"auditor_model":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"parent":"champion-v1","champion_score":0.8704,"challenger_parts":{"score":0.8981486111111111,"worlds":24,"cost":0.05555555555555556,"accuracy":0.9537041666666667},"candidate":"gemini-1260","receipt_digest":"ea36bfbf31d39010","challenger_score":0.8981,"champion_parts":{"score":0.8703722222222222,"worlds":24,"cost":0.11111111111111112,"accuracy":0.9814833333333333},"verdict":"PROMOTED","diff":{"samples_per_arm":[200,400]},"reason":"beat the champion on held-out worlds by the required margin"},"trials":[],"config":{"challenger":{"parent":"champion-v1","effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":200,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"gemini-1260","paired_arms":false},"margin":0.02,"n_worlds":24,"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"trust_observation":false,"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"digest":"fd52c9a392d2c9c3","notes":"","provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","models":{"proposer":"gemini-3.6-flash","auditor":"gemini-3.5-flash-lite"},"image":"metascience-00012-sh4","python":"3.13.15","schema_version":1,"recorded_at":1788206227.3510635}},{"created_at":1788210068.6527815,"kind":"discovery","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[61287],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T7+T5","model":{"X3->X7":-1.2393,"X5->X8":-1.0544},"variables":["X3","X1","X5","X8","X7"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T7+T5","complex_vars":{"X2":["X3","X4"]},"hidden":["X4","X6"],"edges":{"X6":[],"X4":[],"X7":["X3","X6"],"X5":["X4"],"X1":["X3","X4"],"X8":["X5","X6"],"X3":[]},"mechanisms":{"X5":{"form":"imag","const":-0.3258,"coeffs":{"X4":0.5154}},"X7":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X6":1.0442,"X3":-1.2456}},"X1":{"form":"modulus","const":-0.4434,"coeffs":{"X4":0.9552,"X3":1.3115}},"X8":{"form":"linear","const":0,"coeffs":{"X6":1.0365,"X5":-1.0899}}}},"world_seed":61287,"refutations":10,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.008,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0008,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X8","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0164,"cause":"X7"},{"n":400,"effect":"X7","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.008,"cause":"X8"},{"n":400,"effect":"X7","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-1.2393,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.008,"cause":"X7"},{"n":400,"effect":"X7","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0036,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0103,"cause":"X7"},{"n":400,"effect":"X8","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-1.0544,"cause":"X5"},{"n":400,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0042,"cause":"X8"},{"n":400,"effect":"X5","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0009,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0103,"cause":"X5"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":0.75,"mae":0.121,"probes":8}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00013-4tj","recorded_at":1788210068.654678,"python":"3.13.15","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"7dc861f5689f3993","run_id":"discovery-1788210068652-1ff75a","notes":"depth=1 complex=True"},{"created_at":1788210078.291015,"kind":"discovery","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[1977],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T7","model":{},"variables":["X2","X4","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T7","complex_vars":{"X5":["X2","X1"]},"hidden":["X1"],"edges":{"X4":["X2","X1"],"X1":[],"X2":[],"X3":["X1"]},"mechanisms":{"X4":{"form":"modulus","const":0.235,"coeffs":{"X1":1.2977,"X2":0.7142}},"X3":{"form":"imag","const":-0.2182,"coeffs":{"X1":0.6396}}}},"world_seed":1977,"refutations":6,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0021,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.01,"cause":"X4"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0008,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.01,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X4","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0033,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-0.0008,"cause":"X4"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":0.5,"mae":0.1703,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00013-4tj","recorded_at":1788210078.2918973,"python":"3.13.15","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"abdfb05da9362e70","run_id":"discovery-1788210078291-c5c35b","notes":"depth=0 complex=True"},{"created_at":1788210084.7092686,"kind":"discovery","config":{"strategy":{"parent":null,"effect_threshold":0.15,"trust_observation":false,"replications":1,"samples_per_arm":400,"screen_observationally":true,"contrast":[-1.0,1.0],"max_experiments":12,"name":"champion-v1","paired_arms":false}},"seeds":[1977],"outcome":null,"trials":[{"template_id":"T4","model":{"X1->X3":-3.9379,"X1->X2":2.3886,"X2->X3":-1.651},"variables":["X1","X2","X3"],"ground_truth":{"template_id":"T4","complex_vars":{},"hidden":[],"edges":{"X1":[],"X2":["X1"],"X3":["X2"]},"mechanisms":{"X2":{"form":"saturating","const":3.5293,"coeffs":{"X1":2.0886}},"X3":{"form":"linear","const":0.654,"coeffs":{"X2":-1.6469}}}},"world_seed":1977,"refutations":3,"experiments":[{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-1.651,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0334,"cause":"X3"},{"n":400,"effect":"X2","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":2.3886,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0144,"cause":"X2"},{"n":400,"effect":"X3","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"SUPPORTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":-3.9379,"cause":"X1"},{"n":400,"effect":"X1","lo":-1.0,"predicted_sign":-1,"basis":"observational association","verdict":"REFUTED","hi":1.0,"measured_effect":0.0144,"cause":"X3"}],"held_out":{"direction_accuracy":1.0,"mae":0.8044,"probes":4}}],"provenance":{"git_commit":"unknown","schema_version":1,"image":"metascience-00013-4tj","recorded_at":1788210084.710279,"python":"3.13.15","models":{"reasoner":"heuristic"}},"digest":"abdfb05da9362e70","run_id":"discovery-1788210084709-c5c35b","notes":""}]}